Friday, 19 April 2013

A guest post on Patricia Leitch

This post actually appeared as a comment on my post on 1970s pony literature. I enjoyed it so much I felt it was a shame it was buried in the comments. It deserves to be read, so here it is, and many thanks to Laura for writing it. I hope you don't mind being moved to a starring role!



I'm now a university lecturer in English Literature, though struggled with reading from about the age of 9 through to 13. Patricia Leitch's books kept me reading and thinking during that time and, most importantly, they kept alive in me the notion of a life of the imagination. The book that I loved most was Dream of Fair Horses, which I still reread.... it is really a book about what it means to have relationships that aren't driven by possessiveness.


One of the rather melancholy aspects of Patricia Leitch's work that I think I sensed as a child, but that I see much more clearly now, is her anxiety about what it means to be live as an adult woman. The books sometimes seem to share Jinny's disappointment in seeing characters like Sue getting interested in boys and makeup, and this process of growing up, or at least growing up in a particular way, is almost always represented as a loss of real identity. 




In terms of the adult women in the books, Gill's rather spectral mother is happy so long as she can support her brilliant father; Jinny's mother doesn't even have a first name, only coming alive in the glimmers of memory she has about her own girlhood. Miss Tuke is a strong and valuable character in the Jinny books, but a caricature, really, with very little psychological depth. There is a telling moment in Dream of Fair Horses where a girl comments on the woman who runs the down-at-heel riding school, saying how 'terrific' she is. Gill says, 'I was cold to think what it must be like to wake up in the night and know that you were Jennifer'. It's very poignant, and striking, that adult women who are in relationships seem to lose themselves, and those who hold on to their own passions usually find themselves alone.





 Only Gill and the end of Dream of Fair Horses offer the barely glimpsed possibility of another kind of relationship, in which her identity can remain intact. Perhaps one of the things all these girls are waiting for is the opportunity to lead adult lives where they can continue to think and work and love passionately and imagine and create. I'm grateful for the fact that feminism made it more possible for girls brought up in the 70s to make such lives for themselves than those brought up in the 40s/50s, as Leitch was.


The American printing of Dream of Fair Horses

I'm also grateful to Patricia Leitch's books for bringing to life girls who refuse to give up their passions. This demand for something other than what society was handing out and which seems linked to Leitch's wild and sometimes frighteningly unforgiving sense of landscape – a sense that oddly reminds me of Moby-Dick as much as anything (a book that Ken tells Jinny she'll appreciate when she's older, I seem to remember) – is one of the reasons why Jinny, in particular, can be so irritating and impossible. It is also the reason why I value her, and Gill, and Patricia's work. 



~  0 ~

Ride Like the Wind, the eighth Jinny book, has just been republished by Catnip. It's £5.99, and is available from the usual sources.

7 comments:

Hannah Hooton said...

How very interesting and insightful. I can remember warming to Jinny but also finding her quite frustrating at times! The Jinny and Shantih (love that name still!) books are the only ones I've read of Leitch's but I remember they had a lasting effect on me, especially her relationship with the tinkers, and Ken v. Miss Tuke - there were some valuable lessons to be learned on how to treat society and how society treats us.

madwippitt said...

One of my all-time favourite pony books too - Dream of Fair Horses seemed so real, so possible - and although the ending wasn't what I wanted, it stayed true to life rather than an unbelievable fairy tale ending. I still re-read it and get the same enjoyment out of it as an adult.

didyoueverstoptothink said...

I love this and have just tweeted a link to it - the Jinny books were such a favourite of mine. I had a soft spot for Bramble :)

susannaforrest said...

Nell was perhaps one exception – she was living a creative life as an adult, although she does disappear from Jinny's life.
Thank you for this post. It's exactly what struck me too as I re-read the books for If Wishes Were Horses. The phenomenon of the golden horses seemed to sum up writing to me: trying, seeing, recording, then losing some of the magic when you read over again. I took great comfort from it.

horseridesnetus said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

Oh - how nice to see this comment given a new life as a guest blogpost and sorry to have only noticed such a very long time later! Yes, Nell is an exception, and athough she disappoints Jinny by falling in love and moving away, the book does seems to understand it and allows her to live in the Camargue, with wild horses close by, we are can imagine. Btw, I loved your book, Susanna. Thank you for writing so thoughtfully about the passions of girls. -- Laura

Jane Badger said...

I'm sorry too for being a bit slow noticing this. Thank you very much for writing the original piece!